Websites are emotional experiences. People rarely remember your color palette or your menu structure. They remember how the site made them feel. Welcome or lost. Respected or rushed.
That matters most for organizations whose work depends on trust. A nonprofit asking for a donation, a public health agency explaining a vaccine schedule, a city helping someone apply for assistance. In each case, the person on the other side of the screen may already be stressed. The site either lowers that stress or adds to it.
Every design choice is an act of empathy or a missed opportunity. A slow site says, "Your time doesn't matter." Confusing navigation says, "Figure it out yourself." A clean, responsive site says, "We care about your experience."
Here are the ten feelings a good website should never cause, the common mistakes behind each one, and how to fix them.
1. Confused
What causes it: Weak visual hierarchy. When everything is loud, nothing is clear. Vague copy that hides what you actually do. Navigation labels written in internal jargon.
The fix: Say what you do in the first sentence a visitor reads. Give each page one primary message and one primary action. Use the words your audience uses, not your program names. If you have to explain a label, change the label.
2. Rushed
What causes it: Auto-advancing carousels, countdown timers, pop-ups that appear before someone has read a sentence, and forms that time out.
The fix: Let people move at their own pace. Remove auto-rotation or give it a visible pause control. Delay sign-up prompts until someone has engaged with the page. Never punish a slow reader.
3. Judged
What causes it: Error messages that blame the user ("Invalid input"). Forms that demand information without saying why. Copy that assumes everyone has the same knowledge, income, or ability.
The fix: Write error messages that explain and help: "Please enter your ZIP code so we can show nearby clinics." Ask only for what you need. Validate forms gently and keep what someone already typed.
4. Lost
What causes it: Cluttered navigation, broken links, and 404 pages that lead nowhere. Each one erodes trust.
The fix: Organize navigation around tasks, not your org chart. Run a broken link check every quarter. Make your 404 page useful, with search and links to your most-visited pages. Redirect old URLs when content moves.
5. Overwhelmed
What causes it: Walls of text, too many competing calls to action, and homepages that try to feature every program at once.
The fix: Edit ruthlessly. Break long content into sections with clear headings. Choose a single primary action per page. Use white space generously. Restraint is a form of respect.
6. Ignored
What causes it: Ignoring mobile. Many of the people nonprofits and public agencies serve rely on their phones. Tiny tap targets that frustrate thumbs. Layouts that require pinching and zooming.
The fix: Design for mobile first, then scale up. Make buttons and links large enough to tap easily. Test on real phones, including older ones on slower connections.
7. Distracted
What causes it: Auto-playing audio or video, excessive animation, and background effects that pull attention from the content. Some of these once looked modern. Now they mostly get in the way.
The fix: Never auto-play sound. Use motion only when it guides attention or explains something. Respect the reduced motion setting on people's devices. Sometimes empathy means letting go of design tricks that no longer serve.
8. Tricked
What causes it: Dark patterns. Pre-checked boxes for recurring donations, buttons that say one thing and do another, unsubscribe links hidden in gray text.
The fix: Make every choice clear and every default honest. If you want monthly donors, make the case for monthly giving. Don't sneak it in. Trust earned honestly lasts longer than a conversion won through confusion.
9. Small
What causes it: Overused stock imagery that erases your story. Polished photos of models who look nothing like your community. Copy that talks about your organization instead of the people you serve.
The fix: Use real photos of your real community, with permission. Center the people you serve in the story. I once worked with a nonprofit that prided itself on compassion, but its site told a different story. It was slow, cluttered, and filled with generic stock photos. We stripped it down, improved speed, simplified navigation, and replaced the stock images with photos of the actual community. Donor engagement went up almost immediately.
10. Exhausted
What causes it: Slow pages. Long forms with no progress indicator. Processes that make people start over after an error.
The fix: Performance is empathy. Compress images, limit heavy scripts, and test load times on mobile networks. Break long forms into short steps with a progress bar. Save progress so people can come back.
Accessibility belongs on this list too
Poor color contrast excludes people by design. So do images without alt text, videos without captions, and pages you can't navigate with a keyboard. Accessibility is not a separate project. It is part of every feeling on this list. My guide to Section 508 and accessible color explains how to test for it.
How storytelling fixes the feelings
The fixes above are tactical. Storytelling is the strategy that holds them together. Story gives structure to experience. It turns a collection of pages into a path.
Here is what a story-driven site does well:
Clarifies purpose. A clear narrative tells people why you exist before it tells them what you do.
Builds trust. Real people and real outcomes are more credible than claims.
Guides decisions. A story has a beginning, middle, and next step. So should a donation path or an application process.
Reduces friction. When people understand where they are in a process, they relax.
Creates memory. People forget statistics. They remember a person.
Humanizes your organization. Especially for public agencies, story can make a system feel like a service.
Aligns teams. A shared story helps every department write in the same direction.
Simplifies complexity. Complex programs become understandable through one person's experience.
Encourages empathy. Story invites the visitor to see through someone else's eyes.
Improves conversion. People act when they care, and they care when they connect.
A quick self-audit
Open your site on your phone. Pretend you are a first-time visitor with one task, such as donating, registering, or finding a clinic. Time yourself. Note every moment you feel any of the ten feelings above. Then ask two people outside your organization to do the same.
When I point out these issues in audits, teams often say, "I never thought of it that way." That moment is where better design starts.
Frequently asked questions
What is user-centered web design?
It means making decisions based on what your audience needs and how they behave, not on internal preferences. Research, testing, and accessibility are its core tools.
How do we know which problems to fix first?
Start where frustration meets your most important action. A confusing donation page matters more than an awkward About page.
Do we need a full redesign to fix these?
Not always. Many fixes are content and settings changes. If the problems run deep, my website redesign checklist will help you decide.
Build a website that feels like a welcome mat
Want a site that feels like a welcome mat, not a maze? Explore my website design services. If your website is working against you instead of for you, let's fix it.
Related guides: Website redesign checklist ยท Nonprofit call to action examples